A hospital alone shows what war is. (263)
Paul Baumer enlisted in the German army as a very young man who had learned about mathematics, proper grammatical structure, and the philosophy behind the Roman Republic. He did not take a test on warfare; neither did he learn uniform theorems for the way in which battles are conducted. Once Paul reaches the ravaged trenches and the stench of death, however, he becomes quickly indoctrinated into a unique school of thought. He quickly forgets the texts from his class with Kantorek, and his mind is transformed to a primitive state in which survival, not problem solving, is the aim. This metamorphosis ultimately occurs, although over a period of time and a number of experiences and harrowing scenes. Perhaps the most shocking and influential of these sights and experiences derive from Paul’s time spent in hospitals. Once Paul reaches the end of his life on the Western front, his psyche has been wasted by the war. As he reflects, “All that meets me, all that floods over me are but feelings—greed of life, love of home, yearning for the blood, intoxication of deliverance. But no aims” (294). Paul calmly describes the horrors around him during battle, but the hospital scenes demonstrate an even more intense gravity to Paul as the full brutality of the war is realized rather than a sampling of only Paul’s individual perspective.
The first time Paul enters a field hospital, from the reader’s point-of-view, is his platoon’s visit to see the ailing Kemmerich who has just lost a foot in an amputation procedure. While in combat, Paul appears to focus entirely on the battle at hand, and death and destruction, while he chooses to describe it, is tuned out of his survivalist, animalistic behavior. Therefore, his time in the hospital allows Paul to see the effects of war on another man in a situation separated from battle. In such an instance, the devastation on the human body is highlighted. Paul takes the time to notice that Kemmerich’s “features have become uncertain and faint, like a photographic plate from which two pictures have been taken. Even his voice sounds like ashes” (15). Paul notices not only Kemmerich’s poor physical state, the state that most associate with the troubles of war, but also his deteriorating mentality and attitude. Kemmerich slowly abandons his struggle and accepts his knowledge that he is to die soon. Additionally, the conflict over who has the right to Kemmerich’s airman’s boots illustrates the priorities of war. The soft leather boots are, in all honesty, more treasured by the majority of soldiers than is Kemmerich’s health. Young men come and go, but a quality pair of boots is not to be found often. Besides Paul, the German soldiers face few qualms about asking Kemmerich for his boots while he is lying on his deathbed. The men are undoubtedly sympathetic towards Kemmerich’s condition, but war centers around survival, so the men, especially Muller, are preoccupied with obtaining the boots. So many have already been killed that Kemmerich’s death is hardly disturbing.
Paul’s second trip to the hospital results from a shrapnel injury. During his recovery, he is nursed, along with Albert Kropp, in a Catholic mission. The weeks in this facility are perhaps the most telling of what life is like in war. They panic over the rumor that the doctor may amputate their feet for scientific analysis, always fearing some form of unexpected attack or pain, just as in war. They watch dying men be carried downstairs to the Dying Room, none to return except one brave man. It is as if the Dying Room represents the trenches in their minds while remaining in bed upstairs will keep them out of harm’s way. Just as on the front lines, Paul and Kropp have restricted freedoms, and their little enjoyment comes from smashing glasses on the wall. As their stay lengthens, Paul and Kropp watch man after man suffer and die in rapid succession. “In the afternoon Franz Wachter’s bed has a fresh occupant. A couple of days later they take the new man away, too. Josef makes a significant glance. We see many come and go” (257). Also, despite the men’s fair distance from the battleground, they still remain out of contact with their loved ones. It is a massive operation to secure Lewandowski a few minutes with his wife.
Paul’s last and most horrible experience in a hospital arrives when Kat, his best friend, is hit in the leg. Paul slings him over his back and treks the distance to the nearest dressing station. After much struggle and pain, Paul arrives and thinks to himself, “Kat is saved.” Paul’s jubilation is quickly shattered when he finds that a minute piece of shrapnel found Kat’s head just minutes before, killing him instantly.
The war on the front lines quickly forces Paul into manhood as he witnesses friends die and men suffer before death. The three hospital experiences Paul undergoes show his progression into the state of mind that the war is senseless and his future is void of importance. He first watches a friend die, then witnesses countless deaths and hopeless cases in the Catholic infirmary, and his best friend is finally killed in Paul’s bloody arms.